Ramblings of an Eccentric Soul... |
An MBA grad student @ Thunderbird School of Global Management, a musician, a gadget-freak, a committed geek, a doodler, a babbler, a cook, a lover of the simple things in life, a proud T-bird... I am available on a lot of services. You can access them here - Renganathan Ramamoorthy When I find time, I am usually writing at |
Something I’ve always prided myself in doing and evangelizing within SISL, is do it right the first time. I should also thank Vivek in helping me do this, being the project leader he was :)
Jack Cheng quoted Adam Wiggins’ Order of Operations for writing code:
- Make it work.
- Make it elegant.
- Make it fast.
- Make it secure.
I disagree. The biggest problem is that this ignores reality: once it works, how likely are you to go back and make it elegant, fast, and secure? If it’s for personal use, how likely are you to care? If it’s for work, how likely is your employer to be willing to devote resources to “clean up” something that already works? Even the best developers, and the best employers, are pretty bad at this.
You should be writing elegant code very early in the process. There’s always room for improvement, of course, but there’s never an excuse to write sloppy code, even if it’s only running once and you’re the only person ever seeing it.
“Make it fast” can arguably be a lower priority for simple optimizations and constant-time reductions. But algorithmic complexity needs to be considered from the beginning.
And saving “Make it secure” for last seems like a disaster. Imagine how you’d feel, and how you’d even begin to tackle this problem, if someone handed you a pile of another programmer’s code and said, “Make this secure.”
Write good code the first time.
Something I’ve always prided myself in doing and evangelizing within SISL, is do it right the first time. I should also...
1. Drink some coffee 2. Say you’ve got it working 3. Figure out a way it might work 4. Fail to get that working 5. Say...
My guess is that Dave and Marco have different ideas of what it means for code to be elegant. To me, elegant code is...
Good code should be written by default as a standard. There’s always room and time later on for improvements, expansion...
I completely agree with Marco.
Charles exalts the merits of Red, Green, Refactor development, which is similar. I think it’s OK to make things work...
first time. Marco, thank you. I wish everyone had the same understanding...any code....
Couldn’t agree more. In the late eighties and early nineties I was producing embedded code for Rolls Royce and Lucas...
Agree with Marco. Usually this approach doesn’t work. The same problem with unit test and javadocs in Java - if you...
I disagree with Marco, unless the problem and solution are already perfectly defined (which is rare). In a world of fast...
Agreed. Part of being an engineer (by education and trade) is balancing trade-offs: code elegance vs. code speed vs. my...
Jack Cheng quoted Adam Wiggins’...for writing code:...I...
apologise Ben, you’re putting...first couple of steps into practice.